Mario vs Pokemon: Who Would Win? Expert Analysis Reveals the Victor

The debate between the beloved gaming icons Mario and Pokémon has sparked curiosity and speculation among fans for years. Both franchises have incredibly dedicated fanbases, and as the universes expand and their characters’ abilities transform, the question of who would win in a battle between Mario and various Pokémon becomes increasingly complex.

Mario has been the face of Nintendo for decades, showcasing his wide range of abilities as a plumber, kart racer, soccer player, and more, all while navigating his unique and often-dangerous universes. On the other hand, Pokémon, a world filled with magical creatures possessing various elemental powers and unique abilities, has captured the hearts of millions. The Pokémon franchise has grown exponentially since its creation, resulting in hundreds of creatures with diverse skills that one could potentially pit against the likes of Mario.

Key Takeaways

  • The Mario vs. Pokémon debate centers around the strengths, abilities, and universes of these iconic characters.
  • Comparing Mario and various Pokémon involves analyzing their stats, power levels, and how battles unfold in their respective games.
  • The outcome of such battles is a combination of in-universe factors, fan perspectives, and each character’s unique abilities and limitations.

Character Overview


Mario, Nintendo’s iconic and beloved character, has been an integral part of gaming culture since his debut in 1981. Originally known as “Jumpman” in Donkey Kong, Mario has evolved into a versatile protagonist with numerous abilities and power-ups throughout his games. As a character, Mario possesses remarkable jumping skills, athleticism, and a wide range of power-ups such as the Super Mushroom, Fire Flower, and the Super Star. His signature move is his jump, which allows him to defeat enemies, break blocks, and reach higher platforms.

Additionally, Mario’s power-ups provide extra abilities that can give him an edge in a battle. Some of the most notable power-ups include:

  • Fire Mario: With the Fire Flower, Mario can shoot fireballs at enemies, which may prove useful against certain Pokémon.
  • Invincible Mario: When Mario obtains the Super Star, he becomes invincible for a short period, making him immune to all forms of damage.


Pokémon, on the other hand, are a diverse group of over 800 creatures with various types, abilities, and strengths. In the Pokémon franchise, trainers often capture and train these creatures to battle each other in a strategic manner. Each Pokémon has its own set of moves and passive abilities that can be used in a potential showdown.

Some notable Pokémon abilities include:

  • Type advantage: In the Pokémon universe, certain types are strong or weak against others (e.g., water is strong against fire, while electric is strong against water). This plays a crucial role in determining a Pokémon’s effectiveness in battle.
  • Stat-boosting moves: Pokémon can increase their own statistics such as attack, defense, and speed using specific moves, giving them an edge over opponents.
  • Status conditions: Some Pokémon can inflict status conditions on their adversaries, including paralysis, confusion, and sleep, which can hinder an opponent’s functionality in battle.

Overall, both Mario and Pokémon have their own unique strengths and weaknesses. The outcome of a battle between the two would depend on various factors, such as the specific Pokémon selected, the abilities of both characters, and the strategic implementation of their moves.

Game and Media Context

Both Mario and Pokémon franchises have a rich history in the world of gaming and media. They have managed to create a lasting impact on the industry and continue to provide entertainment to fans worldwide.

In terms of games, the Mario series, created by Nintendo in 1985, is mainly characterized by its platform and action-adventure style gameplay. With titles such as Super Mario Bros., Mario Kart, and Super Mario 3D World, the franchise offers a variety of challenges and gaming experiences. In contrast, Pokémon, launched in 1996, focuses on capturing, training, and battling creatures called Pokémon for a more strategic and role-playing game experience. Aside from their main series like Pokémon Red/Blue and Pokémon Sword/Shield, there are also sub-series such as Pokémon Mystery Dungeon and Pokémon Go.

When it comes to anime, Pokémon is unrivaled. The TV series has been running since 1997, chronicling the adventures of Ash Ketchum and his friends as they explore the world of Pokémon. Meanwhile, Mario has not had a strong presence in the world of television. Although there have been various animated and live-action adaptations featuring Mario, none have reached the same level of longevity and popularity as Pokémon.

In the art aspect, both franchises have distinct styles that set them apart from each other. Mario’s aesthetic is bright and colorful, featuring a cast of memorable characters such as Mario, Luigi, Princess Peach, and Bowser. On the other hand, Pokémon has a wide variety of creatures, each with its unique design and personality. This has led to numerous spin-offs and collaborations, resulting in a plethora of Pokémon-themed merchandise, including toys, cards, and clothing.

Comparing the two franchises’ impact, one might argue that Pokémon has a more extensive influence due to its successful anime series, trading card game, and merchandise. However, Mario remains iconic in the gaming industry, with a versatile set of games and a recognizable cast. Both franchises have managed to captivate the hearts of fans, offering different experiences that cater to varying preferences.

Strengths and Powers

Mario’s Powers and Abilities

Mario, the iconic character from the Super Mario series, possesses a wide range of powers and abilities that he uses to overcome obstacles and defeat his enemies. Here are some of his most notable powers:

  • Super Jump: Mario can jump great heights and cover long distances, allowing him to dodge attacks and reach otherwise inaccessible areas.
  • Fire Flower: This power-up grants Mario the ability to throw fireballs, giving him a ranged attack against his foes.
  • Ice Flower: With this power-up, Mario can throw ice balls, which can freeze opponents and make them vulnerable to attacks.
  • Super Mushroom: The Super Mushroom makes Mario grow bigger and stronger, allowing him to take more damage and deal increased damage to enemies.
  • Invincibility Star: Temporarily granting Mario invincibility, the Invincibility Star allows him to pass through enemies and obstacles without taking damage.

Pokémon’s Types and Base Stats

Pokémon come in various types, each with their unique strengths and weaknesses. There are 18 different types, including Normal, Fire, Water, Electric, Grass, Ice, Fighting, Poison, Ground, Flying, Psychic, Bug, Rock, Ghost, Dragon, Dark, Steel, and Fairy. In addition to their typing, each Pokémon has a set of base stats, which determine their performance in battle. These stats include:

  • HP (Hit Points): The amount of damage a Pokémon can take before fainting.
  • Attack: Determines the power of a Pokémon’s physical moves.
  • Defense: Measures a Pokémon’s resistance to physical attacks.
  • Special Attack: Determines the power of a Pokémon’s special moves (e.g., Elemental attacks).
  • Special Defense: Measures a Pokémon’s resistance to special attacks.
  • Speed: Dictates the order of turns in battle, with faster Pokémon attacking before slower ones.

Each Pokémon’s type and base stats have a significant impact on a Pokémon’s performance in battle. For example, a Fairy-type Pokémon might be strong against a Fighting-type, but weak against a Steel-type. As such, understanding the strengths and weaknesses of different types, as well as a Pokémon’s base stats, is crucial for determining which ones Mario would be able to defeat and which ones would defeat him.

Comparing Stats and Power Levels

Superhero Database Calculations

According to the Superhero Database (SHDB), we can see some interesting comparisons between Mario and various Pokémon in terms of stats, overall performance, and power levels. The SHDB classifies characters based on their UStats score, which takes into account various factors such as strength, speed, intelligence, power, and durability.

For Mario, the SHDB UStats score is as follows:

  • Strength: 38
  • Speed: 50
  • Durability: 45
  • Power: 59
  • Combat: 100

Comparing these numbers with a powerful Pokémon like Mewtwo, we find that Mewtwo has the following SHDB UStats:

  • Strength: 85
  • Speed: 97
  • Durability: 70
  • Power: 146
  • Combat: 100

Comparing Key Traits

When analyzing Mario and Pokémon, it’s important to compare some key traits that play a vital role in their battles and overall performance.

Level: In the Pokémon universe, levels play a crucial role in determining the strength and abilities of each creature. However, Mario doesn’t follow a level-based system, which makes it difficult to draw direct comparisons. So, we can rely on UStats scores and other factors to gauge their strength.

Stats: The SHDB UStats illustrate the battle prowess of both Mario and Pokémon characters. When we compare the stats of Mario and Mewtwo, we can see that Mewtwo’s higher strength, speed, durability, and power would likely give it an advantage.

Overall: Although Mario has the same combat score as Mewtwo, the vast difference in power, strength, and speed heavily favors Mewtwo.

Super Power Score (SPS): This metric is used by the SHDB to categorize the overall power and abilities of each character, with a higher score being indicative of a stronger character. In this case, Mewtwo has a significantly higher SPS than Mario, further solidifying its advantage.

Tier: Characters are often ranked in tiers based on their abilities and power. For example, Mewtwo is considered a higher-class character in terms of power and abilities, while Mario is considered a lower class.

In conclusion, when comparing stats and power levels, it seems that Pokémon, specifically Mewtwo, have a significant advantage over Mario. However, battles are not solely determined by stats and power levels, as strategy and specific abilities can also play a crucial role in determining the outcome.

Battles and Fights

Hypothetical Fight Scenarios

In a hypothetical fight between Mario and various Pokémon, several factors come into play, such as strength (str), combat (com), intelligence (int), and speed (spe). For each scenario, we will consider variables such as energy, damage, and opponent’s abilities.

  • Mario vs. Dragonite: Dragonite, a Dragon and Flying type Pokémon, has an advantage in terms of flight and powerful moves like Dragon Claw and Hurricane. However, Mario’s agility and combat skills may help in dodging and counterattacking. Additionally, Mario’s ability to use power-ups, like the Cape Feather or Super Star, could help significantly in battles.

  • Mario vs. Groudon: Groudon, a Ground type Pokémon, is a formidable opponent due to its massive size and powerful moves like Earthquake and Eruption. However, as shown in a source, Mario could potentially defeat Groudon using F.L.U.D.D., to wash him away. Mario’s speed would be an asset in avoiding Groudon’s slower, but higher damage attacks.

Notable Battles from History

In the broader context of Mario vs. Pokémon, there have not been many official battles or encounters between the two franchises in history. However, here are some references to noteworthy discussions or match-ups involving the two universes:

  • Mario vs. Pikachu: In a Pokémon Tournament, Mario faced Goku in the first round, implying that Mario could potentially stand up against powerful opponents like electric rodents.

  • Team Super Mario (Mario) vs. Team Ash (Pokémon): In a Superhero Battle match, teams led by Mario and Ash faced off. Although specific details were not provided, it is an interesting example of crossover between the two worlds.

When comparing Mario and Pokémon in battles, it is crucial to think about the many unique abilities, power-ups, strategies, and characteristics of both sides. By analyzing each characteristic, we can better understand various match-ups and outcomes.

In-Universe and Fan Perspectives

Popular Whowouldwin Posts

Whowouldwin is a subreddit where fans debate hypothetical battles between characters from various universes. Mario vs Pokémon scenarios are quite popular in this forum. Fans consider various aspects, such as their in-game abilities, power-ups, and type match-ups while discussing these hypothetical battles. It is important to note that the discussions and opinions presented in the Whowouldwin subreddit are not official or authoritative but provide a fascinating look into the minds of fans.

Character Roles in their Respective Universes

In the Super Mario universe, Mario is a versatile character. He has various power-ups, such as Ice Flower, Fire Flower, and Super Mushroom, which significantly enhance his abilities. Some fans argue that Mario could potentially defeat certain Pokémon, like Rayquaza, using his Ice Flower power-up, making Rayquaza’s dual-typing a hindrance. However, as a plumber and hero in his own right, Mario is quite different from a typical Pokémon trainer.

On the other hand, Pokémon is a universe filled with diverse creatures with unique abilities and types. These characters engage in battles under the guidance of their trainers. While Mario’s abilities can give him some advantages against certain Pokémon, it is essential to remember that Pokémon are often battling and evolving, honing their skills even further.

Both Mario and Pokémon have a rich history and have evolved continuously over the years, resulting in advanced gameplay mechanics, complex character interactions, and an expanding fanbase across generations. Technology advancements have also made it possible for these characters to be enjoyed beyond their native game platforms. Mario and Pokémon now appear in various media, from apps and animated TV series to movies and merchandise. Through the omnichannel presence, these characters continue to capture the imaginations of fans around the world.

In summary, exploring the In-Universe and Fan Perspectives of Mario vs Pokémon provides valuable insights into the popularity of these beloved characters. Fans engage in debates and discussions that draw upon the rich history and in-game mechanics of both universes. Although head-to-head comparisons may not be entirely fair or definitive, these debates serve as a testament to the impact, significance, and widespread appeal of Mario and Pokémon across various platforms and generations.


In the epic showdown between Mario and Pokémon, the outcome is determined by various factors and situations. Mario, with his array of power-ups, displays super strength and agility. However, the vast world of Pokémon offers a diverse selection of creatures with distinct abilities and strengths, which can prove challenging for Mario.

Considering the array of challenges presented to Mario in his adventures and the level of difficulty that the Pokémon world presents, this battle could sway in favor of either side, depending on the chosen Pokémon and Mario’s access to power-ups. For instance, if Mario had his Fire Flower or Super Star power-ups, he would stand a better chance against a number of Pokémon. Nonetheless, certain powerful Pokémon could still defeat Mario, even with his many abilities.

Ultimately, the winner in a Mario versus Pokémon showdown would depend on specific matchups and circumstances. Both universes are diverse and filled with countless opportunities for an epic face-off. Whether a plumber or a pocket monster reigns supreme remains open for debate, but one thing is for sure: it would be a thrilling encounter for both fans and competitors alike.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who can defeat Mario?

There are several powerful Pokémon that could potentially defeat Mario, such as Groudon, who is weak against Water-types. Mario would have to put in a great deal of effort and not let up on Groudon, no matter how difficult the battle becomes. Other Pokémon like Nidoking also present a significant challenge for Mario.

What is more popular: Mario or Pokémon?

Both Mario and Pokémon franchises have a massive fan base and have been highly successful over the years. It’s difficult to determine which is more popular, as this may vary depending on personal preferences, age groups, and regions.

Could Mario beat Sonic in a fight?

The outcome of a battle between Mario and Sonic is highly debated among fans. While Mario has his power-ups and abilities, Sonic has immense speed. The winner may depend on the specific circumstances and strategies employed during the battle.

Who would win: Goku or Mario?

Given Goku’s extraordinary powers and abilities as a seasoned fighter, it is generally agreed that he would have the upper hand against Mario. While Mario has various power-ups that make him strong, they likely would not be enough to match Goku’s prowess in combat.

How do Mario and Pokémon characters compare in terms of abilities?

Mario has a range of power-ups that enhance his abilities, such as the Fire Flower, Super Mushroom, and Starman. Pokémon, on the other hand, have numerous types with individual strengths and weaknesses based on their typing, moves, and stats. Each Pokémon has up to four moves that they can use in battle, making them versatile fighters with unique capabilities.

What factors determine the winner in a Mario vs. Pokémon battle?

There are several factors to consider while determining the winner of a Mario vs. Pokémon battle. These factors include the specific Pokémon chosen, their type advantages and weaknesses, Mario’s available power-ups, and the strategies employed during the battle. Additionally, elements like battle location, experience, and unique skills also play a critical role.

Scroll to Top